{"schema_version":3,"build":"2026-09-08.3","assessments":[{"schema_version":3,"id":"alexander-951-reviewed-position","subject":"Glasgow-951","status":"approved","reviewed":"2026-09-06","basis":"The maintained conclusion in the supplied dossier, not a new examination of the register.","source":{"url":"/people/glasgow-951.json","section":"research_findings / Current conclusion / 6 September 2026"},"summary":"Alexander’s household is documented at Lisnagaver in 1851. The current research favours the Gortahar death of 16 May 1888. Robert, Mary and Ann are documented children; James is strongly identified. Alexander’s own parents remain unresolved.","vitals":{"death":{"date":"1888-05-16","place":"Gortahar","status":"strongly_supported","country":"ireland","label":"High-confidence identification","note":"The master review identifies the Gortahar death as the leading identification. The recorded age conflicts with the 1851 census; Nancy has not been proved identical to Ann.","source_url":"https://www.irishgenealogy.ie/files/civil/deaths_returns/deaths_1888/06179/4766466.pdf"}},"relationships":[{"target":"Glasgow-938","group":"children","status":"proved","label":"Documented child"},{"target":"Glasgow-3167","group":"children","status":"proved","label":"Documented child"},{"target":"Glasgow-438","group":"children","status":"proved","label":"Documented child"},{"target":"Glasgow-973","group":"children","status":"strongly_supported","label":"Strongly identified child"},{"target":"Glasgow-1367","group":"parents","status":"superseded","label":"Earlier proposal; not established","display":"alternative"},{"target":"Unknown-540856","group":"parents","status":"unknown","label":"Imported attachment; not established","display":"alternative"},{"target":"Glasgow-3904","group":"parents","status":"possible","label":"Uncertain working father","display":"proposed"}],"question":"Which record establishes Alexander’s parentage? Older Alexander and Rosanna are working possibilities, not established parents.","supersedes":["Imported death place: Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland, United Kingdom","Atlas numeric death year: 1861","Imported Robert/Catherine attachments do not establish parentage."],"events":[{"evidence_id":"E-579b3a72a59a","kind":"mention","date":"1866-04-05","label":"Named as Robert’s father","place":"Churchtown, Tamlaght O’Crilly, County Londonderry","role":"Father of the groom","event_type":"marriage","note":"Robert Glasgow’s marriage to Jane Graham names his father Alexander, a farmer. The imported evidence combines this marriage with the 1851 census; this date is the marriage date, not an event in Alexander’s own marital history.","participants":[{"id":"Glasgow-938","role":"Groom"},{"id":"Graham-21720","role":"Bride"},{"id":"Glasgow-951","role":"Father of the groom"}]},{"evidence_id":"E-d57ea52d5952","kind":"personal","date":"1851","label":"Farmer at Lisnagaver","role":"Head of household","event_type":"census","participants":[{"id":"Glasgow-951","role":"Head of household"}]},{"evidence_id":"E-1167ee55ceaa","kind":"family","label":"Earlier Gortereagh baptism references","role":"Relationship to this Alexander unresolved","note":"These early baptism references remain wider family evidence. They are not placed among Alexander’s own life events; the supplied association does not establish that the adult named there is this Alexander."}],"records_policy":{"superseded_places":["scotland","wicklow"],"note":"Retained imported association. The maintained assessment favours the Gortahar death; the Scottish migration is documented for the next generation."}}]}