{"schema_version":"1.0","id":"Eadie-646","alternate_ids":[],"catalogue_id":"eadie-646","name":"Ann Kerr","canonical_url":"https://glasgow.phenotype.dev/people/eadie-646.html","json_url":"https://glasgow.phenotype.dev/people/eadie-646.json","network_url":"https://glasgow.phenotype.dev/people/eadie-646.network.json","wikitree_url":"https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Eadie-646","vitals":{"birth":{"date":"1794-12-05","place":"Dunblane, Stirlingshire, Scotland","status":"exact"},"death":{"date":"1866-05-29","place":"Stirling, Stirlingshire, Scotland, United Kingdom","status":"exact"}},"identity":{"gender":"Female","occupations":[],"locations":["Dunblane, Stirlingshire, Scotland","Stirling, Stirlingshire, Scotland, United Kingdom"],"aliases":[],"research_clusters":[]},"relationships":{"parents":[],"spouses":[{"id":"Kerr-14419","name":"William Kerr","relationship":"spouse","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree tree relationship","basis":"tree","evidence_ids":[],"tree_relationship":true,"relationship_source":"wikitree_spouse_field","tree_status":"unmarked","tree_status_label":"WikiTree: relationship status unmarked","url":"/people/kerr-14419.html","json_url":"/people/kerr-14419.json","network_url":"/people/kerr-14419.network.json","wikitree_url":"https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Kerr-14419","claim_id":"C-d2f13193e2d7"}],"children":[],"siblings":[]},"claims":[{"id":"C-d2f13193e2d7","type":"tree_relationship","subject_ids":["Eadie-646","Kerr-14419"],"claim":"WikiTree currently connects Ann Kerr and William Kerr as spouse.","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree tree relationship","evidence_ids":[],"notes":"Tree structure only; no documentary conclusion is implied.","provenance":"wikitree_spouse_field"}],"evidence":[{"id":"E-18a419766e76","claim_ids":[],"record_type":"extracted citation","date":null,"place":null,"subjects":["Eadie-646"],"assertion":"Citation extracted from the WikiTree profile; its underlying record has not been interpreted here.","evidence_status":"unassessed","source_quality":"derivative","independence_group":"SRC-ade314b56af0","source":{"title":"\"Scotland, Births and Baptisms, 1564-1950,\" FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:VQ7P-M29 : accessed 2 September 2026), Ann Eadie, born 5 December and christened 7 December 1794 at Dunblane, daughter of John Eadie.","repository":null,"reference":null,"url":"https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:VQ7P-M29"},"provenance":"wikitree_profile_citation"},{"id":"E-9b104ef9595f","claim_ids":[],"record_type":"extracted citation","date":null,"place":null,"subjects":["Eadie-646"],"assertion":"Citation extracted from the WikiTree profile; its underlying record has not been interpreted here.","evidence_status":"unassessed","source_quality":"derivative","independence_group":"SRC-e72da25020e6","source":{"title":"\"Statutory Register of Deaths,\" database, National Records of Scotland, ScotlandsPeople (https://www.scotlandspeople.gov.uk/) (image accessed 15 September 2025), Ann Eadie death registered 1866 in Stirling (age 70, mother's maiden name Crawford); citing Ref 490/145.","repository":null,"reference":null,"url":"https://www.scotlandspeople.gov.uk/"},"provenance":"wikitree_profile_citation"}],"open_questions":[{"id":"Q-189a33cc7d68","question":"Which records prove the subject's identity across events?","status":"unresolved","current_conclusion":null,"claim_ids":[],"evidence_for":[],"evidence_against":[],"missing_bridge":null,"lead_ids":[],"provenance":"research/Eadie-646/research_plan.json"},{"id":"Q-df5b71c5c2b8","question":"Which original or indexed records identify the parents?","status":"unresolved","current_conclusion":null,"claim_ids":[],"evidence_for":[],"evidence_against":[],"missing_bridge":"A contemporary record explicitly identifying the parent or parents.","lead_ids":[],"provenance":"research/Eadie-646/research_plan.json"},{"id":"Q-c7aaf31f6819","question":"Which spouses and children are directly supported by records?","status":"unresolved","current_conclusion":null,"claim_ids":[],"evidence_for":[],"evidence_against":[],"missing_bridge":null,"lead_ids":[],"provenance":"research/Eadie-646/research_plan.json"},{"id":"Q-ddc6f6bd9607","question":"What conflicts or same-name conflations must be resolved?","status":"unresolved","current_conclusion":null,"claim_ids":[],"evidence_for":[],"evidence_against":[],"missing_bridge":null,"lead_ids":[],"provenance":"research/Eadie-646/research_plan.json"}],"research_leads":[],"source_summary":[{"title":"\"Scotland, Births and Baptisms, 1564-1950,\" FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:VQ7P-M29 : accessed 2 September 2026), Ann Eadie, born 5 December and christened 7 December 1794 at Dunblane, daughter of John Eadie.","url":"https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:VQ7P-M29","source_quality":"derivative","independence_group":"SRC-ade314b56af0","provenance":"wikitree_profile_citation"},{"title":"\"Statutory Register of Deaths,\" database, National Records of Scotland, ScotlandsPeople (https://www.scotlandspeople.gov.uk/) (image accessed 15 September 2025), Ann Eadie death registered 1866 in Stirling (age 70, mother's maiden name Crawford); citing Ref 490/145.","url":"https://www.scotlandspeople.gov.uk/","source_quality":"derivative","independence_group":"SRC-e72da25020e6","provenance":"wikitree_profile_citation"}],"warnings":[],"provenance":{"tree":"WikiTree One-Tree export","mapped_records":"Glasgow Surname Project map dataset","profile_capture":"Public WikiTree profile evidence capture","relationship_assessments":"Controlled local relationship hypothesis register","research_findings":"Durable research/<profile-or-catalogue-ID>/findings.md case file"},"research_findings":[{"profile_id":"Eadie-646","updated":"2026-09-02","source_path":"research/Eadie-646/findings.md","sections":[{"title":"Current conclusion","category":"conclusion","markdown":"[Ann Eadie (Eadie-646)](https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Eadie-646) has no attached\nparents. The evidence strongly identifies her parents as **John Eadie** and\n**Helen Crawford**, but new WikiTree profiles should remain **HOLD** until two\nplausible existing-profile candidates are resolved.\n\nThe live profile now records Ann's exact birth on **5 December 1794**, retains\nher 7 December baptism, cites the stable FamilySearch baptism, and records the\nFamilySearch parent PIDs with duplicate cautions. No structural parent links\nwere added: [John Adie (Adie-192)](https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Adie-192) and\n[Helen Crawford (Crawford-30067)](https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Crawford-30067)\nremain unresolved candidates.\n\nThe parent relationship itself is well supported by three mutually consistent\nrecords:\n\n1. Ann's indexed Dunblane baptism names her father as John Eadie.\n2. John Eadie married Helen Crawford at Dunblane in 1787, seven years before\n   Ann's birth.\n3. Ann's 1866 statutory death registration names both parents, John Eadie and\n   Helen Crawford.\n\nThis is enough to treat the names as Ann's record-supported parents. It is not\nenough to accept the unsupported FamilySearch birth estimates for the parents\nor to bypass the WikiTree duplicate candidates."},{"title":"Source findings","category":"sources","markdown":"| Source | Exact finding | Assessment |\n| --- | --- | --- |\n| [FamilySearch baptism VQ7P-M29](https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:VQ7P-M29), *Scotland, Births and Baptisms, 1564-1950* | Ann Eadie, female, born **5 December 1794**; christened **7 December 1794** at Dunblane, Perthshire; father **John Eadie**. Digital folder `007908023`, film `1040066`, batch `C11348-5`. The record image is unavailable. | Direct indexed evidence for Ann's father. The live profile now distinguishes the birth and baptism dates and cites this record. The index does not name Ann's mother or John's age, birthplace, wife or parents. |\n| National Records of Scotland, Old Parish Register marriages, Dunblane parish 348, reference `30/371` | John Eadie and Helen Crawford married or proclaimed on **3 June 1787** at Dunblane. | Primary-register citation for the couple in the right parish before Ann's birth. The original image was not accessible in this pass, so any additional wording, residences or occupations remain unverified. |\n| National Records of Scotland, statutory death register, Stirling 1866, reference `490/145` | Ann Eadie died **29 May 1866**, aged 70, at 72 Cowan Street, Stirling; widow of William Kerr, shoemaker. Her parents were recorded as **John Eadie, ploughman**, and **Helen Crawford**. | Direct parentage evidence. The live profile says the image was accessed on 15 September 2025, but it could not be reopened here. The informant and whether either parent was marked deceased should be checked on the image before drafting parent vitals. |\n| [FamilySearch Ann Eadie (LB5X-GZP)](https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/LB5X-GZP) | Matching Ann, 5 December 1794-29 May 1866, attached to [John Eadie (97PX-LJJ)](https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/97PX-LJJ) and [Helen Crawford (97BY-1DF)](https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/97BY-1DF); their marriage is shown as 3 June 1787 at Dunblane. | Useful identity alignment, not independent proof. Ann has seven attached sources. |\n| FamilySearch parent profiles | John is shown born 7 April 1758 at Dunblane; Helen is shown born about 1763 in Scotland. | Do **not** use these dates as facts. Both birth fields show zero attached sources. Helen's year was explicitly estimated as twenty years before the first child's birth. John's exact date says “as per birth record,” but no attached source or matching historical-record result was exposed. The tree also contains a pre-marriage child and an unrelated-looking Isabella Forbes, so its reconstructed child list is not reliable as a unit. |\n\nThe occupation difference—John as a stocking maker in Ann's baptism narrative\nand as a ploughman in Ann's death registration—does not by itself identify two\nmen. Occupations could change over seventy years, and a child's death informant\nmay have known only a general occupation. The original baptism and death images\nshould nevertheless be compared before writing John's biography."},{"title":"WikiTree duplicate audit","category":"assessment","markdown":"### John Eadie\n\nSearches covered `Eadie`, `Edie` and `Adie`, about 1758, Dunblane and wider\nScotland.\n\n- [John Eadie (Eadie-583)](https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Eadie-583), born 7\n  December 1766 at Falkirk and died 7 February 1839 at Dysart, is a different\n  indexed identity. His profile has no spouse or children but the exact\n  Falkirk birth and Fife death do not match FamilySearch's unsupported 1758\n  Dunblane reconstruction.\n- [John Edie (Edie-396)](https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Edie-396), born before\n  14 January 1768 at Logie, Fife, and died in 1800, is geographically distinct\n  and has a separate documented identity.\n- [John Adie (Adie-192)](https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Adie-192), born 24\n  October 1765 at Muthill, Perthshire, is a **plausible candidate**, not a\n  rejected duplicate. He would have been 21 at the 1787 marriage, Muthill is\n  within the regional Perthshire network, and his profile has no spouse,\n  children or death. Its baptism names Andrew Adie and Elizabeth Cairns\n  ([FamilySearch VQWQ-W76](https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:VQWQ-W76)).\n  No record yet connects or excludes him from the Dunblane marriage.\n\nNo existing WikiTree profile was found for a John Eadie born 1758 at Dunblane\nand married to Helen Crawford. `Adie-192` must be resolved before creating a\nnew John.\n\n### Helen Crawford\n\nSearches covered Helen, Ellen and Hellen Crawford, about 1763, Dunblane and\nwider Scotland.\n\n- [Helen Crawford (Crawford-30067)](https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Crawford-30067),\n  born about June 1769 and baptised 8 July 1769 at Maybole, Ayrshire, daughter\n  of Archibald Crawford and Helen Nievine, is a **weak but unresolved\n  candidate**. She would have been about 17 or 18 at the Dunblane marriage and\n  her profile has no spouse, children or death. The Maybole-to-Dunblane move is\n  unsupported but not impossible.\n- Helen Beveradge Crawford, Helen Cherry Crawford and Helen Armstrong Crawford\n  are women whose birth surnames were not Crawford and are not candidates for\n  Ann's mother.\n\nNo exact WikiTree profile was found for Helen Crawford, wife of John Eadie at\nDunblane. `Crawford-30067` should be compared against the marriage and later\nfamily records before creating a new Helen."},{"title":"Recommended action","category":"actions","markdown":"**HOLD profile creation and linking for now.** The names John Eadie and Helen\nCrawford can safely be reported as Ann's parents, but it is not yet safe to\ncreate new WikiTree profiles because `Adie-192` and `Crawford-30067` remain\npossible matches.\n\nThe evidence update to `Eadie-646` is complete; this HOLD applies only to\ncreating or attaching structural parent profiles.\n\nResolve the hold by:\n\n1. inspecting NRS marriage image `348/30/371` for residence, status,\n   occupation, witnesses or other distinguishing wording;\n2. reopening death image `490/145` to capture the informant, exact occupations\n   and deceased status;\n3. inspecting the original Dunblane baptisms for Ann and the couple's other\n   record-supported children for repeated occupation/residence details; and\n4. testing those details against `Adie-192` and `Crawford-30067`.\n\nIf both candidates are excluded, create separate minimally stated profiles:\nJohn Eadie, stocking maker/ploughman, married 3 June 1787 at Dunblane; and\nHelen Crawford, married there on the same date. Leave their births, deaths and\nparents uncertain unless separately proved, then attach both to `Eadie-646`\nwith the baptism, marriage and statutory-death citations.\n\nThis parent set is counted in the completed fan-root register because the\nrelationship is directly supported, but the unresolved duplicate candidates\nstill prevent safe profile creation or live attachment."}]}],"similar_people":[],"potential_parentage":{"children_recorded":[],"earliest_dated_son":null,"earliest_dated_daughter":null,"second_dated_son":null,"second_dated_daughter":null,"third_dated_son":null,"third_dated_daughter":null,"naming_controls":{"matches":0,"mismatches":0,"factor":1.0,"details":[]},"candidates":[],"method":"Automated leads use birth surnames—not married surnames—as parental eligibility, role-specific biological age limits, bounded and approximate-date uncertainty, household chronology, specific time-aware localities, mapped distance, tenancy succession, migration destinations and sex-aware Scottish naming positions across generations. People already attached as the subject's parents stay in the identity summary and are excluded from this alternative-candidate list, regardless of relationship confidence. The main calibration uses clues available on disconnected profiles; existing parent and sibling links are retained as comparison context rather than treated as transferable evidence. Common ordered names and grandparent-to-child echoes receive a small non-zero weight, so a John or James match can support several independent criteria without producing a lead alone. Rare names, repeated bearers and bundles across otherwise distinct branches receive substantially more weight according to catalogue frequency. An exact migration place is weighted by its rarity and repetition across both branches; a shared destination country is worth only one point. Extra weight is added only when at least three independent clue types converge: naming, locality, specific migration, household chronology or collateral networks. Sparse profiles retain a clearly labelled chronology-only fallback instead of disappearing. Countries, states, counties and research clusters do not count as a shared locality, and fallback, broad representative or kin-inferred coordinates are excluded from distance scoring. Shared descendant profiles are removed before branch-name comparison. A candidate already recorded as a parent-in-law is excluded. A confident or independently supported parent is treated as settled; uncertain and unassessed attachments remain open to alternative comparison. A different linked parent, an uncle/aunt or grandparent path, and a matching existing child profile prevent an alternative from being classified as a strong direct-parent lead until the underlying tree conflict or duplicate is resolved. Familiar forms such as Bessie are normalised. Surname remains an eligibility filter worth zero points.","warning":"Naming customs, shared farms and occupations are circumstantial. Children, spouses and collateral relatives may be missing, and tree-derived family networks are not independent evidence. Scores rank research leads; they do not prove parentage."},"presentation":{"version":"21","position":{"answer":"Ann Eadie (Eadie-646) has no attached parents. The evidence strongly identifies her parents as John Eadie and Helen Crawford, but new WikiTree profiles should remain HOLD until two plausible existing-profile candidates are resolved.","points":[]},"opening":"Ann Eadie (Eadie-646) has no attached parents. The evidence strongly identifies her parents as John Eadie and Helen Crawford, but new WikiTree profiles should remain HOLD until two plausible existing-profile candidates are resolved.","assessment_date":"2026-09-02","resolution":{"state":"resolved","basis":["maintained Current conclusion finding"],"issues":[],"source_ids":["research/Eadie-646/findings.md"]},"record_associations":[],"vitals":{"birth":{"date":"1794-12-05","place":"Dunblane, Stirlingshire, Scotland","status":"exact"},"death":{"date":"1866-05-29","place":"Stirling, Stirlingshire, Scotland, United Kingdom","status":"exact"}},"relationships":{"parents":[],"spouses":[{"id":"Kerr-14419","name":"William Kerr","relationship":"spouse","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree tree relationship","basis":"tree","evidence_ids":[],"tree_relationship":true,"relationship_source":"wikitree_spouse_field","tree_status":"unmarked","tree_status_label":"WikiTree: relationship status unmarked","url":"/people/kerr-14419.html","json_url":"/people/kerr-14419.json","network_url":"/people/kerr-14419.network.json","wikitree_url":"https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Kerr-14419","claim_id":"C-d2f13193e2d7"}],"children":[],"siblings":[]}}}