{"schema_version":"1.0","id":"Hutcheson-1652","alternate_ids":[],"catalogue_id":"hutcheson-1652","name":"Helen Hill","canonical_url":"https://glasgow.phenotype.dev/people/hutcheson-1652.html","json_url":"https://glasgow.phenotype.dev/people/hutcheson-1652.json","network_url":"https://glasgow.phenotype.dev/people/hutcheson-1652.network.json","wikitree_url":"https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Hutcheson-1652","identity":{"gender":"Female","occupations":[],"locations":["Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland"],"aliases":[],"research_clusters":[]},"evidence":[{"id":"E-5b4371fd5526","claim_ids":[],"record_type":"extracted citation","date":null,"place":null,"subjects":["Hutcheson-1652"],"assertion":"Citation extracted from the WikiTree profile; its underlying record has not been interpreted here.","evidence_status":"unassessed","source_quality":"unknown","independence_group":"SRC-a3a9e7507927","source":{"title":"Early Records of an Old Glasgow Family*, W.H. Hill (1902), pp. 36–65 [https://deriv.nls.uk/dcn23/9556/95565896.23.pdf]","repository":null,"reference":null,"url":"https://deriv.nls.uk/dcn23/9556/95565896.23.pdf"},"provenance":"wikitree_profile_citation"},{"id":"E-2d5add6a9637","claim_ids":[],"record_type":"extracted citation","date":null,"place":null,"subjects":["Hutcheson-1652"],"assertion":"Citation extracted from the WikiTree profile; its underlying record has not been interpreted here.","evidence_status":"unassessed","source_quality":"unknown","independence_group":"SRC-e6b22efe2f34","source":{"title":"The History of Glasgow, Volume 2, Chapter XX* [https://www.electricscotland.com/history/glasgow/glasgow2_20.htm]","repository":null,"reference":null,"url":"https://www.electricscotland.com/history/glasgow/glasgow2_20.htm"},"provenance":"wikitree_profile_citation"},{"id":"E-d4e818e3e253","claim_ids":[],"record_type":"extracted citation","date":null,"place":null,"subjects":["Hutcheson-1652"],"assertion":"Citation extracted from the WikiTree profile; its underlying record has not been interpreted here.","evidence_status":"unassessed","source_quality":"unknown","independence_group":"SRC-88d98d09bda5","source":{"title":"George Hutcheson’s Will, 18 April 1639","repository":null,"reference":null,"url":null},"provenance":"wikitree_profile_citation"},{"id":"E-91f84b923fc7","claim_ids":[],"record_type":"extracted citation","date":null,"place":null,"subjects":["Hutcheson-1652"],"assertion":"Citation extracted from the WikiTree profile; its underlying record has not been interpreted here.","evidence_status":"unassessed","source_quality":"unknown","independence_group":"SRC-b13ea9261ed1","source":{"title":"Glasgow Town Clerks’ Records","repository":null,"reference":null,"url":null},"provenance":"wikitree_profile_citation"},{"id":"E-8b1905d39cb5","claim_ids":[],"record_type":"extracted citation","date":null,"place":null,"subjects":["Hutcheson-1652"],"assertion":"Citation extracted from the WikiTree profile; its underlying record has not been interpreted here.","evidence_status":"unassessed","source_quality":"unknown","independence_group":"SRC-c02c2ccd3345","source":{"title":"The Old Country Houses of the Old Glasgow Gentry*, VIII. Barlanark [http://gdl.cdlr.strath.ac.uk/smihou/smihou008.htm]","repository":null,"reference":null,"url":"http://gdl.cdlr.strath.ac.uk/smihou/smihou008.htm"},"provenance":"wikitree_profile_citation"}],"open_questions":[],"research_leads":[],"source_summary":[{"title":"Early Records of an Old Glasgow Family*, W.H. Hill (1902), pp. 36–65 [https://deriv.nls.uk/dcn23/9556/95565896.23.pdf]","url":"https://deriv.nls.uk/dcn23/9556/95565896.23.pdf","source_quality":"unknown","independence_group":"SRC-a3a9e7507927","provenance":"wikitree_profile_citation"},{"title":"The History of Glasgow, Volume 2, Chapter XX* [https://www.electricscotland.com/history/glasgow/glasgow2_20.htm]","url":"https://www.electricscotland.com/history/glasgow/glasgow2_20.htm","source_quality":"unknown","independence_group":"SRC-e6b22efe2f34","provenance":"wikitree_profile_citation"},{"title":"George Hutcheson’s Will, 18 April 1639","url":null,"source_quality":"unknown","independence_group":"SRC-88d98d09bda5","provenance":"wikitree_profile_citation"},{"title":"Glasgow Town Clerks’ Records","url":null,"source_quality":"unknown","independence_group":"SRC-b13ea9261ed1","provenance":"wikitree_profile_citation"},{"title":"The Old Country Houses of the Old Glasgow Gentry*, VIII. Barlanark [http://gdl.cdlr.strath.ac.uk/smihou/smihou008.htm]","url":"http://gdl.cdlr.strath.ac.uk/smihou/smihou008.htm","source_quality":"unknown","independence_group":"SRC-c02c2ccd3345","provenance":"wikitree_profile_citation"}],"warnings":[],"provenance":{"tree":"WikiTree One-Tree export","mapped_records":"Glasgow Surname Project map dataset","profile_capture":"Public WikiTree profile evidence capture","relationship_assessments":"Controlled local relationship hypothesis register","research_findings":"Maintained research case files; inclusion reviewed in research-catalogue-cases.json","father_status_refresh":"Live WikiTree readback, 28 September 2026"},"research_findings":[{"profile_id":"Hutcheson-1652","updated":null,"source_path":"research/Hutcheson-1652/findings.md","sections":[{"title":"Current conclusion","category":"conclusion","markdown":"The father relationship with [Thomas Hutcheson](https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Hutcheson-1647) is assessed as **uncertain**. Relationship rests on property connections, will legatees and compiled-family reconstruction."},{"title":"Father relationship assessment — 28 September 2026","category":"assessment","markdown":"This is a review of existing evidence, not a newly discovered record. Attached father: [Thomas Hutcheson](https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Hutcheson-1647). Assessment: **uncertain**.\n\nReason: Relationship rests on property connections, will legatees and compiled-family reconstruction.\n\nSource summary: live biography citing W.H. Hill and George Hutcheson's 1639 will. Saved on WikiTree and verified in the live edit form on 28 September 2026; only the father certainty and its explanation were updated."}]}],"similar_people":[],"potential_parentage":{},"vitals":{"birth":{"date":"1575","place":"Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland","status":"uncertain"},"death":{"date":"1654","place":"Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland","status":"uncertain"}},"relationships":{"parents":[{"id":"Hutcheson-1647","name":"Thomas Hutcheson","url":"/people/hutcheson-1647.html","json_url":"/people/hutcheson-1647.json","network_url":"/people/hutcheson-1647.network.json","wikitree_url":"https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Hutcheson-1647","assertion_id":"C-father-audit-20260928-hutcheson-1647-hutcheson-1652","status":"uncertain","basis":"Reviewed father relationship evidence and live WikiTree certainty audit, 28 September 2026","source_ids":[],"source_summary":"live biography citing W.H. Hill and George Hutcheson's 1639 will","assessment_date":"2026-09-28","identity_scope":"Specific attached father–child pair; later-life identity questions are assessed separately.","analysis_links":[{"label":"Father evidence and remaining questions","href":"/people/hutcheson-1652.html#archive-tools"}],"publication_status":"approved","provenance":{"source":"/assets/research/relationship-assessments.json","reviewed_at":"2026-09-28","basis":"Review of citations already present in the live biography and maintained findings; no new archival inspection claimed.","live_wikitree_status":"uncertain"},"relationship":"father","reason":"Relationship rests on property connections, will legatees and compiled-family reconstruction. Source review: live biography citing W.H. Hill and George Hutcheson's 1639 will.","claim_id":"C-father-audit-20260928-hutcheson-1647-hutcheson-1652","lifecycle":"current","display":"current","tree_relationship":false,"relationship_source":"shared_research_assertion","status_label":"Uncertain father link","assessment_source":"/assets/research/relationship-assessments.json","record_source":"/assets/research/canonical-records.json","historical_claim_ids":["C-262f9e59e722"]},{"id":"Herbertson-132","name":"Helen Hutcheson Herbertson","relationship":"mother","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree tree relationship","basis":"tree","evidence_ids":[],"tree_relationship":true,"relationship_source":"wikitree_parent_field","tree_status":"unmarked","tree_status_label":"WikiTree: relationship status unmarked","url":"/people/herbertson-132.html","json_url":"/people/herbertson-132.json","network_url":"/people/herbertson-132.network.json","wikitree_url":"https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Herbertson-132","claim_id":"C-35cb25b6c1ac"}],"spouses":[{"id":"Hill-17647","name":"Ninian Hill","relationship":"spouse","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree tree relationship","basis":"tree","evidence_ids":[],"tree_relationship":true,"relationship_source":"wikitree_spouse_field","tree_status":"unmarked","tree_status_label":"WikiTree: relationship status unmarked","url":"https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Hill-17647","json_url":null,"network_url":null,"wikitree_url":"https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Hill-17647","claim_id":"C-be59a6f54795"}],"children":[{"id":"Hill-32630","name":"Margaret Pollock Hill","relationship":"child","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree tree relationship","basis":"tree","evidence_ids":[],"tree_relationship":true,"relationship_source":"reconstructed_parent_reference","tree_status":"unmarked","tree_status_label":"WikiTree: relationship status unmarked","url":"https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Hill-32630","json_url":null,"network_url":null,"wikitree_url":"https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Hill-32630","claim_id":"C-533a0e3bd918"},{"id":"Hill-17207","name":"Ninian Hill","relationship":"child","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree tree relationship","basis":"tree","evidence_ids":[],"tree_relationship":true,"relationship_source":"reconstructed_parent_reference","tree_status":"unmarked","tree_status_label":"WikiTree: relationship status unmarked","url":"https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Hill-17207","json_url":null,"network_url":null,"wikitree_url":"https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Hill-17207","claim_id":"C-4af6b314527b"}],"siblings":[{"id":"Hutcheson-1649","name":"Thomas Hutcheson","relationship":"sibling","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree relationship snapshot","basis":"tree","evidence_ids":[],"tree_relationship":true,"relationship_source":"wikitree_relation_snapshot","url":"/people/hutcheson-1649.html","json_url":"/people/hutcheson-1649.json","network_url":"/people/hutcheson-1649.network.json","wikitree_url":"https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Hutcheson-1649","claim_id":"C-f0026d40c6e5"},{"id":"Hutcheson-1654","name":"Janet Hutcheson","relationship":"sibling","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree relationship snapshot","basis":"tree","evidence_ids":[],"tree_relationship":true,"relationship_source":"wikitree_relation_snapshot","url":"/people/hutcheson-1654.html","json_url":"/people/hutcheson-1654.json","network_url":"/people/hutcheson-1654.network.json","wikitree_url":"https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Hutcheson-1654","claim_id":"C-403d981dba95"},{"id":"Hutcheson-1655","name":"Elizabeth Hutcheson","relationship":"sibling","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree relationship snapshot","basis":"tree","evidence_ids":[],"tree_relationship":true,"relationship_source":"wikitree_relation_snapshot","url":"/people/hutcheson-1655.html","json_url":"/people/hutcheson-1655.json","network_url":"/people/hutcheson-1655.network.json","wikitree_url":"https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Hutcheson-1655","claim_id":"C-c4892055f2e2"}]},"claims":[{"id":"C-262f9e59e722","type":"tree_relationship","subject_ids":["Hutcheson-1652","Hutcheson-1647"],"claim":"WikiTree currently connects Helen Hill and Thomas Hutcheson as father.","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree tree relationship","evidence_ids":[],"notes":"Tree structure only; no documentary conclusion is implied.","provenance":"wikitree_parent_field","lifecycle":"historical","superseded_by":"C-father-audit-20260928-hutcheson-1647-hutcheson-1652","supersession_scope":"The previous relationship assessment is replaced by the reviewed record basis; this does not reject the relationship."},{"id":"C-35cb25b6c1ac","type":"tree_relationship","subject_ids":["Hutcheson-1652","Herbertson-132"],"claim":"WikiTree currently connects Helen Hill and Helen Hutcheson Herbertson as mother.","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree tree relationship","evidence_ids":[],"notes":"Tree structure only; no documentary conclusion is implied.","provenance":"wikitree_parent_field"},{"id":"C-be59a6f54795","type":"tree_relationship","subject_ids":["Hutcheson-1652","Hill-17647"],"claim":"WikiTree currently connects Helen Hill and Ninian Hill as spouse.","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree tree relationship","evidence_ids":[],"notes":"Tree structure only; no documentary conclusion is implied.","provenance":"wikitree_spouse_field"},{"id":"C-533a0e3bd918","type":"tree_relationship","subject_ids":["Hutcheson-1652","Hill-32630"],"claim":"WikiTree currently connects Helen Hill and Margaret Pollock Hill as child.","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree tree relationship","evidence_ids":[],"notes":"Tree structure only; no documentary conclusion is implied.","provenance":"reconstructed_parent_reference"},{"id":"C-4af6b314527b","type":"tree_relationship","subject_ids":["Hutcheson-1652","Hill-17207"],"claim":"WikiTree currently connects Helen Hill and Ninian Hill as child.","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree tree relationship","evidence_ids":[],"notes":"Tree structure only; no documentary conclusion is implied.","provenance":"reconstructed_parent_reference"},{"id":"C-f0026d40c6e5","type":"tree_relationship","subject_ids":["Hutcheson-1652","Hutcheson-1649"],"claim":"WikiTree currently connects Helen Hill and Thomas Hutcheson as sibling.","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree relationship snapshot","evidence_ids":[],"notes":"Tree structure only; no documentary conclusion is implied.","provenance":"wikitree_relation_snapshot"},{"id":"C-403d981dba95","type":"tree_relationship","subject_ids":["Hutcheson-1652","Hutcheson-1654"],"claim":"WikiTree currently connects Helen Hill and Janet Hutcheson as sibling.","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree relationship snapshot","evidence_ids":[],"notes":"Tree structure only; no documentary conclusion is implied.","provenance":"wikitree_relation_snapshot"},{"id":"C-c4892055f2e2","type":"tree_relationship","subject_ids":["Hutcheson-1652","Hutcheson-1655"],"claim":"WikiTree currently connects Helen Hill and Elizabeth Hutcheson as sibling.","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree relationship snapshot","evidence_ids":[],"notes":"Tree structure only; no documentary conclusion is implied.","provenance":"wikitree_relation_snapshot"},{"status":"uncertain","status_label":"Uncertain father link","relationship":"father","reason":"Relationship rests on property connections, will legatees and compiled-family reconstruction. Source review: live biography citing W.H. Hill and George Hutcheson's 1639 will.","basis":"Reviewed father relationship evidence and live WikiTree certainty audit, 28 September 2026","source_ids":[],"identity_scope":"Specific attached father–child pair; later-life identity questions are assessed separately.","analysis_links":[{"label":"Father evidence and remaining questions","href":"/people/hutcheson-1652.html#archive-tools"}],"provenance":{"source":"/assets/research/relationship-assessments.json","reviewed_at":"2026-09-28","basis":"Review of citations already present in the live biography and maintained findings; no new archival inspection claimed.","live_wikitree_status":"uncertain"},"assessment_date":"2026-09-28","assessment_source":"/assets/research/relationship-assessments.json","record_source":"/assets/research/canonical-records.json","id":"C-father-audit-20260928-hutcheson-1647-hutcheson-1652","type":"assessed_relationship","subject_ids":["Hutcheson-1647","Hutcheson-1652"],"perspective_id":"Hutcheson-1652","claim":"Relationship rests on property connections, will legatees and compiled-family reconstruction. Source review: live biography citing W.H. Hill and George Hutcheson's 1639 will.","notes":"Relationship rests on property connections, will legatees and compiled-family reconstruction. Source review: live biography citing W.H. Hill and George Hutcheson's 1639 will.","lifecycle":"current","historical_claim_ids":["C-262f9e59e722"],"evidence_ids":[]}],"imported":{"provenance":{"tree":"WikiTree One-Tree export","mapped_records":"Glasgow Surname Project map dataset","profile_capture":"Public WikiTree profile evidence capture","relationship_assessments":"Controlled local relationship hypothesis register","research_findings":"Maintained research case files; inclusion reviewed in research-catalogue-cases.json","father_status_refresh":"Live WikiTree readback, 28 September 2026"},"sections":{"vitals":{"birth":{"date":"1575","place":"Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland","status":"uncertain"},"death":{"date":"1654","place":"Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland","status":"uncertain"}},"relationships":{"parents":[{"id":"Hutcheson-1647","name":"Thomas Hutcheson","relationship":"father","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree tree relationship","basis":"tree","evidence_ids":[],"tree_relationship":true,"relationship_source":"wikitree_parent_field","tree_status":"uncertain","tree_status_label":"Tree-marked uncertain","url":"/people/hutcheson-1647.html","json_url":"/people/hutcheson-1647.json","network_url":"/people/hutcheson-1647.network.json","wikitree_url":"https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Hutcheson-1647","claim_id":"C-262f9e59e722"},{"id":"Herbertson-132","name":"Helen Hutcheson Herbertson","relationship":"mother","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree tree relationship","basis":"tree","evidence_ids":[],"tree_relationship":true,"relationship_source":"wikitree_parent_field","tree_status":"unmarked","tree_status_label":"WikiTree: relationship status unmarked","url":"/people/herbertson-132.html","json_url":"/people/herbertson-132.json","network_url":"/people/herbertson-132.network.json","wikitree_url":"https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Herbertson-132","claim_id":"C-35cb25b6c1ac"}],"spouses":[{"id":"Hill-17647","name":"Ninian Hill","relationship":"spouse","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree tree relationship","basis":"tree","evidence_ids":[],"tree_relationship":true,"relationship_source":"wikitree_spouse_field","tree_status":"unmarked","tree_status_label":"WikiTree: relationship status unmarked","url":"https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Hill-17647","json_url":null,"network_url":null,"wikitree_url":"https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Hill-17647","claim_id":"C-be59a6f54795"}],"children":[{"id":"Hill-32630","name":"Margaret Pollock Hill","relationship":"child","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree tree relationship","basis":"tree","evidence_ids":[],"tree_relationship":true,"relationship_source":"reconstructed_parent_reference","tree_status":"unmarked","tree_status_label":"WikiTree: relationship status unmarked","url":"https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Hill-32630","json_url":null,"network_url":null,"wikitree_url":"https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Hill-32630","claim_id":"C-533a0e3bd918"},{"id":"Hill-17207","name":"Ninian Hill","relationship":"child","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree tree relationship","basis":"tree","evidence_ids":[],"tree_relationship":true,"relationship_source":"reconstructed_parent_reference","tree_status":"unmarked","tree_status_label":"WikiTree: relationship status unmarked","url":"https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Hill-17207","json_url":null,"network_url":null,"wikitree_url":"https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Hill-17207","claim_id":"C-4af6b314527b"}],"siblings":[{"id":"Hutcheson-1649","name":"Thomas Hutcheson","relationship":"sibling","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree relationship snapshot","basis":"tree","evidence_ids":[],"tree_relationship":true,"relationship_source":"wikitree_relation_snapshot","url":"/people/hutcheson-1649.html","json_url":"/people/hutcheson-1649.json","network_url":"/people/hutcheson-1649.network.json","wikitree_url":"https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Hutcheson-1649","claim_id":"C-f0026d40c6e5"},{"id":"Hutcheson-1654","name":"Janet Hutcheson","relationship":"sibling","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree relationship snapshot","basis":"tree","evidence_ids":[],"tree_relationship":true,"relationship_source":"wikitree_relation_snapshot","url":"/people/hutcheson-1654.html","json_url":"/people/hutcheson-1654.json","network_url":"/people/hutcheson-1654.network.json","wikitree_url":"https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Hutcheson-1654","claim_id":"C-403d981dba95"},{"id":"Hutcheson-1655","name":"Elizabeth Hutcheson","relationship":"sibling","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree relationship snapshot","basis":"tree","evidence_ids":[],"tree_relationship":true,"relationship_source":"wikitree_relation_snapshot","url":"/people/hutcheson-1655.html","json_url":"/people/hutcheson-1655.json","network_url":"/people/hutcheson-1655.network.json","wikitree_url":"https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Hutcheson-1655","claim_id":"C-c4892055f2e2"}]},"claims":[{"id":"C-262f9e59e722","type":"tree_relationship","subject_ids":["Hutcheson-1652","Hutcheson-1647"],"claim":"WikiTree currently connects Helen Hill and Thomas Hutcheson as father.","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree tree relationship","evidence_ids":[],"notes":"Tree structure only; no documentary conclusion is implied.","provenance":"wikitree_parent_field"},{"id":"C-35cb25b6c1ac","type":"tree_relationship","subject_ids":["Hutcheson-1652","Herbertson-132"],"claim":"WikiTree currently connects Helen Hill and Helen Hutcheson Herbertson as mother.","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree tree relationship","evidence_ids":[],"notes":"Tree structure only; no documentary conclusion is implied.","provenance":"wikitree_parent_field"},{"id":"C-be59a6f54795","type":"tree_relationship","subject_ids":["Hutcheson-1652","Hill-17647"],"claim":"WikiTree currently connects Helen Hill and Ninian Hill as spouse.","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree tree relationship","evidence_ids":[],"notes":"Tree structure only; no documentary conclusion is implied.","provenance":"wikitree_spouse_field"},{"id":"C-533a0e3bd918","type":"tree_relationship","subject_ids":["Hutcheson-1652","Hill-32630"],"claim":"WikiTree currently connects Helen Hill and Margaret Pollock Hill as child.","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree tree relationship","evidence_ids":[],"notes":"Tree structure only; no documentary conclusion is implied.","provenance":"reconstructed_parent_reference"},{"id":"C-4af6b314527b","type":"tree_relationship","subject_ids":["Hutcheson-1652","Hill-17207"],"claim":"WikiTree currently connects Helen Hill and Ninian Hill as child.","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree tree relationship","evidence_ids":[],"notes":"Tree structure only; no documentary conclusion is implied.","provenance":"reconstructed_parent_reference"},{"id":"C-f0026d40c6e5","type":"tree_relationship","subject_ids":["Hutcheson-1652","Hutcheson-1649"],"claim":"WikiTree currently connects Helen Hill and Thomas Hutcheson as sibling.","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree relationship snapshot","evidence_ids":[],"notes":"Tree structure only; no documentary conclusion is implied.","provenance":"wikitree_relation_snapshot"},{"id":"C-403d981dba95","type":"tree_relationship","subject_ids":["Hutcheson-1652","Hutcheson-1654"],"claim":"WikiTree currently connects Helen Hill and Janet Hutcheson as sibling.","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree relationship snapshot","evidence_ids":[],"notes":"Tree structure only; no documentary conclusion is implied.","provenance":"wikitree_relation_snapshot"},{"id":"C-c4892055f2e2","type":"tree_relationship","subject_ids":["Hutcheson-1652","Hutcheson-1655"],"claim":"WikiTree currently connects Helen Hill and Elizabeth Hutcheson as sibling.","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree relationship snapshot","evidence_ids":[],"notes":"Tree structure only; no documentary conclusion is implied.","provenance":"wikitree_relation_snapshot"}]}},"data_view":"reviewed","research_assessments":[],"shared_relationship_assertions":["C-father-audit-20260928-hutcheson-1647-hutcheson-1652"],"relationship_history":[{"id":"Hutcheson-1647","name":"Thomas Hutcheson","relationship":"father","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree tree relationship","basis":"tree","evidence_ids":[],"tree_relationship":true,"relationship_source":"wikitree_parent_field","tree_status":"uncertain","tree_status_label":"Tree-marked uncertain","url":"/people/hutcheson-1647.html","json_url":"/people/hutcheson-1647.json","network_url":"/people/hutcheson-1647.network.json","wikitree_url":"https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Hutcheson-1647","claim_id":"C-262f9e59e722","lifecycle":"historical","superseded_by":"C-father-audit-20260928-hutcheson-1647-hutcheson-1652"}],"presentation":{"version":"34","position":{"answer":"The father relationship with Thomas Hutcheson is assessed as uncertain. Relationship rests on property connections, will legatees and compiled-family reconstruction.","points":[]},"opening":"The father relationship with Thomas Hutcheson is assessed as uncertain. Relationship rests on property connections, will legatees and compiled-family reconstruction.","assessment_date":"","resolution":{"state":"resolved","basis":["maintained Current conclusion finding"],"issues":[],"source_ids":["research/Hutcheson-1652/findings.md"]},"record_associations":[],"vitals":{"birth":{"date":"1575","place":"Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland","status":"uncertain"},"death":{"date":"1654","place":"Glasgow, Lanarkshire, Scotland","status":"uncertain"}},"relationships":{"parents":[{"id":"Hutcheson-1647","name":"Thomas Hutcheson","url":"/people/hutcheson-1647.html","json_url":"/people/hutcheson-1647.json","network_url":"/people/hutcheson-1647.network.json","wikitree_url":"https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Hutcheson-1647","assertion_id":"C-father-audit-20260928-hutcheson-1647-hutcheson-1652","status":"uncertain","basis":"Reviewed father relationship evidence and live WikiTree certainty audit, 28 September 2026","source_ids":[],"source_summary":"live biography citing W.H. Hill and George Hutcheson's 1639 will","assessment_date":"2026-09-28","identity_scope":"Specific attached father–child pair; later-life identity questions are assessed separately.","analysis_links":[{"label":"Father evidence and remaining questions","href":"/people/hutcheson-1652.html#archive-tools"}],"publication_status":"approved","provenance":{"source":"/assets/research/relationship-assessments.json","reviewed_at":"2026-09-28","basis":"Review of citations already present in the live biography and maintained findings; no new archival inspection claimed.","live_wikitree_status":"uncertain"},"relationship":"father","reason":"Relationship rests on property connections, will legatees and compiled-family reconstruction. Source review: live biography citing W.H. Hill and George Hutcheson's 1639 will.","claim_id":"C-father-audit-20260928-hutcheson-1647-hutcheson-1652","lifecycle":"current","display":"current","tree_relationship":false,"relationship_source":"shared_research_assertion","status_label":"Uncertain father link","assessment_source":"/assets/research/relationship-assessments.json","record_source":"/assets/research/canonical-records.json","historical_claim_ids":["C-262f9e59e722"]},{"id":"Herbertson-132","name":"Helen Hutcheson Herbertson","relationship":"mother","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree tree relationship","basis":"tree","evidence_ids":[],"tree_relationship":true,"relationship_source":"wikitree_parent_field","tree_status":"unmarked","tree_status_label":"WikiTree: relationship status unmarked","url":"/people/herbertson-132.html","json_url":"/people/herbertson-132.json","network_url":"/people/herbertson-132.network.json","wikitree_url":"https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Herbertson-132","claim_id":"C-35cb25b6c1ac"}],"spouses":[{"id":"Hill-17647","name":"Ninian Hill","relationship":"spouse","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree tree relationship","basis":"tree","evidence_ids":[],"tree_relationship":true,"relationship_source":"wikitree_spouse_field","tree_status":"unmarked","tree_status_label":"WikiTree: relationship status unmarked","url":"https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Hill-17647","json_url":null,"network_url":null,"wikitree_url":"https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Hill-17647","claim_id":"C-be59a6f54795"}],"children":[{"id":"Hill-32630","name":"Margaret Pollock Hill","relationship":"child","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree tree relationship","basis":"tree","evidence_ids":[],"tree_relationship":true,"relationship_source":"reconstructed_parent_reference","tree_status":"unmarked","tree_status_label":"WikiTree: relationship status unmarked","url":"https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Hill-32630","json_url":null,"network_url":null,"wikitree_url":"https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Hill-32630","claim_id":"C-533a0e3bd918"},{"id":"Hill-17207","name":"Ninian Hill","relationship":"child","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree tree relationship","basis":"tree","evidence_ids":[],"tree_relationship":true,"relationship_source":"reconstructed_parent_reference","tree_status":"unmarked","tree_status_label":"WikiTree: relationship status unmarked","url":"https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Hill-17207","json_url":null,"network_url":null,"wikitree_url":"https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Hill-17207","claim_id":"C-4af6b314527b"}],"siblings":[{"id":"Hutcheson-1649","name":"Thomas Hutcheson","relationship":"sibling","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree relationship snapshot","basis":"tree","evidence_ids":[],"tree_relationship":true,"relationship_source":"wikitree_relation_snapshot","url":"/people/hutcheson-1649.html","json_url":"/people/hutcheson-1649.json","network_url":"/people/hutcheson-1649.network.json","wikitree_url":"https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Hutcheson-1649","claim_id":"C-f0026d40c6e5"},{"id":"Hutcheson-1654","name":"Janet Hutcheson","relationship":"sibling","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree relationship snapshot","basis":"tree","evidence_ids":[],"tree_relationship":true,"relationship_source":"wikitree_relation_snapshot","url":"/people/hutcheson-1654.html","json_url":"/people/hutcheson-1654.json","network_url":"/people/hutcheson-1654.network.json","wikitree_url":"https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Hutcheson-1654","claim_id":"C-403d981dba95"},{"id":"Hutcheson-1655","name":"Elizabeth Hutcheson","relationship":"sibling","status":"unknown","status_label":"WikiTree relationship snapshot","basis":"tree","evidence_ids":[],"tree_relationship":true,"relationship_source":"wikitree_relation_snapshot","url":"/people/hutcheson-1655.html","json_url":"/people/hutcheson-1655.json","network_url":"/people/hutcheson-1655.network.json","wikitree_url":"https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Hutcheson-1655","claim_id":"C-c4892055f2e2"}]}}}