Researched biography · Glasgow-3539
Mary Glasgow
c. 1613
Saltcoats, Ayrshire, Scotland
About Mary
Glasgow-3539 represents Mary Glasgow, wife of James Montgomerie, a sailor in Saltcoats in Ardrossan parish. The printed Glasgow Commissary testament index lists her under 24 October 1677. The exact-name spouse, occupation and place make this a coherent profile identity, but the index is only an abbreviated finding aid: it does not state Mary's birth date, parents or exact death date.
Birthc. 1613 · Saltcoats, Ayrshire, Scotland
DeathDate not established
LocalitySaltcoats, Ayrshire, Scotland
Connected pages
Other pages on this site that name Mary Glasgow: family studies, places, source pages and other people's research.
Family and study pages 2 pages
A study page may discuss this person without placing them in that family.
Places 1 place
Sources 2 source pages
What the research found
Summary of the research
Overall conclusion
Mary is not the Agnes Glasgow named in the corrected 1636/37 testament of John Glasgow, sailor in Saltcoats. That record names daughters Katherine and Agnes, not Marie or Mary. The former proposed mapping of Glasgow-3539 into John's household is withdrawn.
The live profile currently estimates Mary's birth as 1613 at Saltcoats and attaches Edward Glasgow and Catherine Hamilton as parents. The 1677 index does not support those details. Preserve the date, location and attached parents while marking them uncertain; no sourced replacement values or parents are ready.
What the records show
Source findings
| Source | Finding | Assessment |
|---|---|---|
| Francis J. Grant, ed., [https://archive.org/details/scottishrecordso07scotuoft/page/196/mode/2up?q=Glasgow%2C ''The Commissariot Record of Glasgow: Register of Testaments, 1547–1800''] (Edinburgh: Scottish Record Society, 1901), p. 196 | Mary, spouse to James Montgomerie, sailor in Saltcoats, par. of Ardrossan 24 Oct. 1677. |
Direct index evidence for Mary's spouse and his occupation/place; the date is the register/index date, not a stated death date. The full testament has not been inspected. |
| National Records of Scotland, Glasgow Commissary Court, CC9/7/27, register pp. 478–480; [https://www.scotlandspeople.gov.uk/search-records/legal-records/wills Scotland's People wills search] | John Glasgow, sailor in Saltcoats, died in December 1636; his widow was Isobell Gray and his lawful children were Katherine and Agnes Glasgow. | Directly excludes the proposed identification of Mary as a daughter named in this record. It does not address Mary Montgomerie's parentage. |
Identity and family
Relationship and identity assessment
- Spouse: James Montgomerie is directly named and should remain attached. The index describes him as a sailor in Saltcoats.
- Father: Edward Glasgow is presently attached, but no inspected source in this file proves the relationship. Preserve it as uncertain until positive evidence identifies Mary's parents.
- Mother: Catherine Hamilton is presently attached, but no inspected source in this file proves the relationship. Preserve it as uncertain until positive evidence identifies Mary's parents.
- Birth: About 1613 is an unsupported estimate in the current live biography. Saltcoats is relevant through James's 1677 description but is not explicitly stated as Mary's birthplace. Preserve both as uncertain rather than blanking populated fields.
- 1637 Saltcoats family: no relationship is established. Mary is neither a named daughter nor a substitute spelling for Agnes in the corrected reading.
Father relationship assessment — 28 September 2026
This is a review of existing evidence, not a newly discovered record. Attached father: Edward Glasgow. Assessment: uncertain.
Reason: The 1677 testament index identifies Mary’s spouse and Saltcoats locality but supplies no parentage; Edward’s attachment remains unproved.
Source summary: The 1677 testament index identifies Mary’s spouse and Saltcoats locality but supplies no parentage; Edward’s attachment remains unproved. Saved on WikiTree and verified in the live edit form on 28 September 2026; only the father certainty and its explanation were updated.
Still open
Questions the records have not yet answered, suggested next searches and suggested corrections.
Recommended profile correction
Use the complete citation-preserving replacement draft in Glasgow-3539.md.
Retain James Montgomerie as spouse. Keep the existing birth
details and parent attachments uncertain until the full 1677 testament or
another record supplies a supported replacement. Do not attach Mary to the
1636/37 household of John Glasgow and Isobell Gray.
Next records
- Inspect the full testament registered under 24 October 1677 for Mary's estate, relatives, residence, debts and any indication of age.
- Search Ardrossan kirk-session and parish material for Mary and James.
- Test the attached Edward Glasgow and Catherine Hamilton against original records; preserve both links unless a sourced replacement is established.
Family and relationships
Unless a link is marked otherwise, the family links below come from the WikiTree family tree and have not yet been checked against original records.
How to read the evidence What “Documented”, “Probable”, “Possible” and “Unassessed tree link” mean.
Parents 2Edward Glasgowc. 1570–date not establishedCatherine (Hamilton) Glasgowc. 1587–date not established
| Person and dates | Relationship | Current assessment | Why this relationship is shown |
|---|---|---|---|
| Edward Glasgow c. 1570–date not established | father | Uncertain father link | The 1677 testament index identifies Mary’s spouse and Saltcoats locality but supplies no parentage; Edward’s attachment remains unproved. |
| Catherine (Hamilton) Glasgow c. 1587–date not established | mother | Unassessed mother link | From the family tree; not yet checked against records. |
Spouse or partner 1James MontgomerieDates not established
| Person and dates | Relationship | Current assessment | Why this relationship is shown |
|---|---|---|---|
| James Montgomerie Dates not established | spouse | Unassessed partner link | From the family tree; not yet checked against records. |
Brothers and sisters 4Jonet Loganc. 1600–date not establishedCristiane Glasgow1 May 1609–date not establishedRobert Glasgow IIc. 1612–c. 1690Edward Glasgow6 June 1615–date not established
| Person and dates | Relationship | Current assessment | Why this relationship is shown |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jonet Logan c. 1600–date not established | sibling | Unassessed sibling link | From the family tree; not yet checked against records. |
| Cristiane Glasgow 1 May 1609–date not established | sibling | Unassessed sibling link | From the family tree; not yet checked against records. |
| Robert Glasgow II c. 1612–c. 1690 | sibling | Unassessed sibling link | From the family tree; not yet checked against records. |
| Edward Glasgow 6 June 1615–date not established | sibling | Unassessed sibling link | From the family tree; not yet checked against records. |
Life and records
Explore the dated recordsChronology, roles and locations
Historical chronology
Profile-stated birthplace: Saltcoats, Ayrshire, Scotland
Record association
Records mentioning this personRecord detail
The profile snapshot records this fact, but it is not an independent historical record; the linked historical evidence is assessed separately.
Birth
Subject
Life eventsSources
The only source so far is the WikiTree profile itselfReferences and source limitations
Profile-stated birthplace: Saltcoats, Ayrshire, Scotland
b. 1613 · Saltcoats — Ayrshire · Source association
The profile snapshot records this fact, but it is not an independent historical record; the linked historical evidence is assessed separately.
Each entry is a separately identified record. Shared URLs may represent one transcription or search page containing more than one record; they are not independent confirmations.
Suggested profile text
WikiTree profile and prepared draft
WikiTree profile text
The prepared text for the public WikiTree profile, kept here so it can be compared with the current profile.
The prepared amendment is already on WikiTree; no pending biography change.
Compared with Glasgow-3539, captured 2026-09-27T23:38:56+00:00 · 2026-09-27.
Current captured WikiTree biography
Read-only capture used for the comparison above.
Side-by-side comparison of the live and replacement profiles
No biography changes in this draft.
Current profileReplacement profile
Current profile1[[Category:Glasgow Name Study]]
Replacement profile1[[Category:Glasgow Name Study]]
Current profile2{{Estimated Date}}
Replacement profile2{{Estimated Date}}
Current profile3== Biography ==
Replacement profile3== Biography ==
Current profile4'''Mary Glasgow''' was the wife of [[Montgomerie-601|James Montgomerie]], who
Replacement profile4'''Mary Glasgow''' was the wife of [[Montgomerie-601|James Montgomerie]], who
Current profile5was described as a sailor in Saltcoats in the parish of Ardrossan. The printed
Replacement profile5was described as a sailor in Saltcoats in the parish of Ardrossan. The printed
Current profile6index to the Glasgow Commissary testament registers lists Mary in that capacity
Replacement profile6index to the Glasgow Commissary testament registers lists Mary in that capacity
Current profile7under 24 October 1677.<ref name="Mary1677">Francis J. Grant, ed.,
Replacement profile7under 24 October 1677.<ref name="Mary1677">Francis J. Grant, ed.,
Current profile8[https://archive.org/details/scottishrecordso07scotuoft/page/196/mode/2up?q=Glasgow%2C
Replacement profile8[https://archive.org/details/scottishrecordso07scotuoft/page/196/mode/2up?q=Glasgow%2C
Current profile9''The Commissariot Record of Glasgow: Register of Testaments, 1547–1800'']
Replacement profile9''The Commissariot Record of Glasgow: Register of Testaments, 1547–1800'']
Current profile10(Edinburgh: Scottish Record Society, 1901), p. 196: “Mary, spouse to James
Replacement profile10(Edinburgh: Scottish Record Society, 1901), p. 196: “Mary, spouse to James
Current profile11Montgomerie, sailor in Saltcoats, par. of Ardrossan,” 24 October 1677.</ref>
Replacement profile11Montgomerie, sailor in Saltcoats, par. of Ardrossan,” 24 October 1677.</ref>
Current profile12
Replacement profile12
Current profile13The index directly supports Mary's marriage to James and identifies his
Replacement profile13The index directly supports Mary's marriage to James and identifies his
Current profile14occupation and place. The date is the testament-register entry date; the index
Replacement profile14occupation and place. The date is the testament-register entry date; the index
Current profile15does not state Mary's exact date of death.<ref name="Mary1677" />
Replacement profile15does not state Mary's exact date of death.<ref name="Mary1677" />
Current profile16
Replacement profile16
Current profile17== Research Notes ==
Replacement profile17== Research Notes ==
Current profile18=== Birth and parentage ===
Replacement profile18=== Birth and parentage ===
Current profile19
Replacement profile19
Current profile20Mary's existing birth year of about 1613 is an estimate for which no supporting
Replacement profile20Mary's existing birth year of about 1613 is an estimate for which no supporting
Current profile21record has yet been identified. Saltcoats is relevant because the 1677 index
Replacement profile21record has yet been identified. Saltcoats is relevant because the 1677 index
Current profile22describes her husband there, but it does not expressly state that Mary was born
Replacement profile22describes her husband there, but it does not expressly state that Mary was born
Current profile23there. The populated date and location should be retained as uncertain while
Replacement profile23there. The populated date and location should be retained as uncertain while
Current profile24better evidence is sought.
Replacement profile24better evidence is sought.
Current profile25
Replacement profile25
Current profile26[[Glasgow-1557|Edward Glasgow]] and [[Hamilton-31734|Catherine Hamilton]] are
Replacement profile26[[Glasgow-1557|Edward Glasgow]] and [[Hamilton-31734|Catherine Hamilton]] are
Current profile27attached as Mary's parents. The 1677 index does not name either parent, and no
Replacement profile27attached as Mary's parents. The 1677 index does not name either parent, and no
Current profile28inspected source presently proves those relationships. The links should remain
Replacement profile28inspected source presently proves those relationships. The links should remain
Current profile29uncertain unless a record establishes specific replacement parents; they
Replacement profile29uncertain unless a record establishes specific replacement parents; they
Current profile30should not simply be removed and left blank.
Replacement profile30should not simply be removed and left blank.
Current profile31
Replacement profile31
Current profile32=== Distinct 1637 household ===
Replacement profile32=== Distinct 1637 household ===
Current profile33
Replacement profile33
Current profile34The testament dative and inventory of John Glasgow, sailor in Saltcoats, is a
Replacement profile34The testament dative and inventory of John Glasgow, sailor in Saltcoats, is a
Current profile35different record. It names Isobell Gray as John's widow and Katherine and
Replacement profile35different record. It names Isobell Gray as John's widow and Katherine and
Current profile36Agnes Glasgow as his lawful children. It does not name Mary or Marie and gives
Replacement profile36Agnes Glasgow as his lawful children. It does not name Mary or Marie and gives
Current profile37no basis for attaching this profile to that household.<ref>National Records of
Replacement profile37no basis for attaching this profile to that household.<ref>National Records of
Current profile38Scotland, Glasgow Commissary Court, testament dative and inventory of John
Replacement profile38Scotland, Glasgow Commissary Court, testament dative and inventory of John
Current profile39Glasgow, sailor in Saltcoats, NRS CC9/7/27, register pp. 478–480; death in
Replacement profile39Glasgow, sailor in Saltcoats, NRS CC9/7/27, register pp. 478–480; death in
Current profile40December 1636 and court proceedings in April 1637; original register re-read
Replacement profile40December 1636 and court proceedings in April 1637; original register re-read
Current profile41September 2026; locate by reference through the
Replacement profile41September 2026; locate by reference through the
Current profile42[https://www.scotlandspeople.gov.uk/search-records/legal-records/wills
Replacement profile42[https://www.scotlandspeople.gov.uk/search-records/legal-records/wills
Current profile43Scotland's People wills search].</ref>
Replacement profile43Scotland's People wills search].</ref>
Current profile44
Replacement profile44
Current profile45The full 1677 testament should be inspected before inferring Mary's age,
Replacement profile45The full 1677 testament should be inspected before inferring Mary's age,
Current profile46parentage, children, property or exact death date from the short printed index.
Replacement profile46parentage, children, property or exact death date from the short printed index.
Current profile47
Replacement profile47
Current profile48== Sources ==
Replacement profile48== Sources ==
Current profile49<references />
Replacement profile49<references />
Full replacement WikiTree biography
Copy this complete text into the WikiTree biography editor. Removed lines appear red on the left; added lines appear green on the right. Apply any structured vital or relationship correction described in the update separately in WikiTree's data fields.
Original notes and downloadsNotes as written, replaced interpretations, comparisons and data exports
The material the page is built from: research notes as originally written, earlier interpretations that have been replaced, automated comparisons and data downloads. The account above is the current one; nothing here overrides it.
Research notes as originally written
Current conclusion
Glasgow-3539 represents Mary Glasgow, wife of [[Montgomerie-601|James Montgomerie]], a sailor in Saltcoats in Ardrossan parish. The printed Glasgow Commissary testament index lists her under 24 October 1677. The exact-name spouse, occupation and place make this a coherent profile identity, but the index is only an abbreviated finding aid: it does not state Mary's birth date, parents or exact death date. Mary is not the Agnes Glasgow named in the corrected 1636/37 testament of John Glasgow, sailor in Saltcoats. That record names daughters Katherine and Agnes, not Marie or Mary. The former proposed mapping of Glasgow-3539 into John's household is withdrawn. The live profile currently estimates Mary's birth as 1613 at Saltcoats and attaches [[Glasgow-1557|Edward Glasgow]] and [[Hamilton-31734|Catherine Hamilton]] as parents. The 1677 index does not support those details. Preserve the date, location and attached parents while marking them uncertain; no sourced replacement values or parents are ready.
Source findings
| Source | Finding | Assessment | | --- | --- | --- | | Francis J. Grant, ed., [https://archive.org/details/scottishrecordso07scotuoft/page/196/mode/2up?q=Glasgow%2C ''The Commissariot Record of Glasgow: Register of Testaments, 1547–1800''] (Edinburgh: Scottish Record Society, 1901), p. 196 | `Mary, spouse to James Montgomerie, sailor in Saltcoats, par. of Ardrossan 24 Oct. 1677.` | Direct index evidence for Mary's spouse and his occupation/place; the date is the register/index date, not a stated death date. The full testament has not been inspected. | | National Records of Scotland, Glasgow Commissary Court, CC9/7/27, register pp. 478–480; [https://www.scotlandspeople.gov.uk/search-records/legal-records/wills Scotland's People wills search] | John Glasgow, sailor in Saltcoats, died in December 1636; his widow was Isobell Gray and his lawful children were Katherine and Agnes Glasgow. | Directly excludes the proposed identification of Mary as a daughter named in this record. It does not address Mary Montgomerie's parentage. |
Relationship and identity assessment
- **Spouse:** [[Montgomerie-601|James Montgomerie]] is directly named and should remain attached. The index describes him as a sailor in Saltcoats. - **Father:** [[Glasgow-1557|Edward Glasgow]] is presently attached, but no inspected source in this file proves the relationship. Preserve it as uncertain until positive evidence identifies Mary's parents. - **Mother:** [[Hamilton-31734|Catherine Hamilton]] is presently attached, but no inspected source in this file proves the relationship. Preserve it as uncertain until positive evidence identifies Mary's parents. - **Birth:** About 1613 is an unsupported estimate in the current live biography. Saltcoats is relevant through James's 1677 description but is not explicitly stated as Mary's birthplace. Preserve both as uncertain rather than blanking populated fields. - **1637 Saltcoats family:** no relationship is established. Mary is neither a named daughter nor a substitute spelling for Agnes in the corrected reading.
Recommended profile correction
Use the complete citation-preserving replacement draft in `Glasgow-3539.md`. Retain [[Montgomerie-601|James Montgomerie]] as spouse. Keep the existing birth details and parent attachments uncertain until the full 1677 testament or another record supplies a supported replacement. Do not attach Mary to the 1636/37 household of John Glasgow and Isobell Gray.
Next records
1. Inspect the full testament registered under 24 October 1677 for Mary's estate, relatives, residence, debts and any indication of age. 2. Search Ardrossan kirk-session and parish material for Mary and James. 3. Test the attached Edward Glasgow and Catherine Hamilton against original records; preserve both links unless a sourced replacement is established.
Father relationship assessment — 28 September 2026
This is a review of existing evidence, not a newly discovered record. Attached father: [Edward Glasgow](https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Glasgow-1557). Assessment: **uncertain**. Reason: The 1677 testament index identifies Mary’s spouse and Saltcoats locality but supplies no parentage; Edward’s attachment remains unproved. Source summary: The 1677 testament index identifies Mary’s spouse and Saltcoats locality but supplies no parentage; Edward’s attachment remains unproved. Saved on WikiTree and verified in the live edit form on 28 September 2026; only the father certainty and its explanation were updated.
Automated parent comparison (research aid, not a recommendation)
Stored scores are preserved for audit only. They are not probabilities or genealogical evidence, and a reviewed exclusion remains excluded.
- George Glasgow: 2/100 · Stored classification: competing linked parent
- Jonet (Glasgow) Stewart: 0/100 · Stored classification: competing linked parent
- Elspeth Glasgow: 0/100 · Stored classification: competing linked parent
- George Glasgow: 0/100 · Stored classification: competing linked parent
- Helen (Glasgow) Broun: 0/100 · Stored classification: competing linked parent
- James Glasgow: 0/100 · Stored classification: competing linked parent
- Alexander Glasgow: 0/100 · Stored classification: competing linked parent
- Barbara Glasgow: 0/100 · Stored classification: competing linked parent
- Catherine (Fraser) Glasgow: 0/100 · Stored classification: competing linked parent
- Hugh Glasgow: 0/100 · Stored classification: competing linked parent
Research data and downloads
Person data (JSON) · Family network
{
"id": "Glasgow-3539",
"vitals": {
"birth": {
"date": "c. 1613",
"place": "Saltcoats, Ayrshire, Scotland",
"status": "estimated"
},
"death": {
"date": null,
"place": null,
"status": null
}
},
"relationships": {
"parents": [
{
"id": "Glasgow-1557",
"name": "Edward Glasgow",
"url": "/people/glasgow-1557.html",
"json_url": "/people/glasgow-1557.json",
"network_url": "/people/glasgow-1557.network.json",
"wikitree_url": "https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Glasgow-1557",
"assertion_id": "C-father-audit-20260928-glasgow-1557-glasgow-3539",
"status": "uncertain",
"basis": "Reviewed father relationship evidence and live WikiTree certainty audit, 28 September 2026",
"source_ids": [],
"source_summary": "The 1677 testament index identifies Mary’s spouse and Saltcoats locality but supplies no parentage; Edward’s attachment remains unproved.",
"assessment_date": "2026-09-28",
"identity_scope": "Specific attached father–child pair; later-life identity questions are assessed separately.",
"analysis_links": [
{
"label": "Father evidence and remaining questions",
"href": "/people/glasgow-3539.html#archive-tools"
}
],
"publication_status": "approved",
"provenance": {
"source": "/assets/research/relationship-assessments.json",
"reviewed_at": "2026-09-28",
"basis": "Review of citations already present in the live biography and maintained findings; no new archival inspection claimed.",
"live_wikitree_status": "uncertain"
},
"relationship": "father",
"reason": "The 1677 testament index identifies Mary’s spouse and Saltcoats locality but supplies no parentage; Edward’s attachment remains unproved.",
"claim_id": "C-father-audit-20260928-glasgow-1557-glasgow-3539",
"lifecycle": "current",
"display": "current",
"tree_relationship": false,
"relationship_source": "shared_research_assertion",
"status_label": "Uncertain father link",
"assessment_source": "/assets/research/relationship-assessments.json",
"record_source": "/assets/research/canonical-records.json",
"historical_claim_ids": [
"C-5574aef09979"
]
},
{
"id": "Hamilton-31734",
"name": "Catherine (Hamilton) Glasgow",
"relationship": "mother",
"status": "unknown",
"status_label": "WikiTree tree relationship",
"basis": "tree",
"evidence_ids": [],
"tree_relationship": true,
"relationship_source": "wikitree_parent_field",
"tree_status": "unmarked",
"tree_status_label": "WikiTree: relationship status unmarked",
"url": "/people/hamilton-31734.html",
"json_url": "/people/hamilton-31734.json",
"network_url": "/people/hamilton-31734.network.json",
"wikitree_url": "https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Hamilton-31734",
"claim_id": "C-5c119b598bb1"
}
],
"spouses": [
{
"id": "Montgomerie-601",
"name": "James Montgomerie",
"relationship": "spouse",
"status": "unknown",
"status_label": "WikiTree tree relationship",
"basis": "tree",
"evidence_ids": [],
"tree_relationship": true,
"relationship_source": "wikitree_spouse_field",
"tree_status": "unmarked",
"tree_status_label": "WikiTree: relationship status unmarked",
"url": "https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Montgomerie-601",
"json_url": null,
"network_url": null,
"wikitree_url": "https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Montgomerie-601",
"claim_id": "C-a162832724b5"
}
],
"children": [],
"siblings": [
{
"id": "Glasgow-1494",
"name": "Jonet Logan",
"relationship": "sibling",
"status": "unknown",
"status_label": "WikiTree relationship snapshot",
"basis": "tree",
"evidence_ids": [],
"tree_relationship": true,
"relationship_source": "wikitree_relation_snapshot",
"url": "/people/glasgow-1494.html",
"json_url": "/people/glasgow-1494.json",
"network_url": "/people/glasgow-1494.network.json",
"wikitree_url": "https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Glasgow-1494",
"claim_id": "C-eb0b62bd28ab"
},
{
"id": "Glasgow-2456",
"name": "Cristiane Glasgow",
"relationship": "sibling",
"status": "unknown",
"status_label": "WikiTree relationship snapshot",
"basis": "tree",
"evidence_ids": [],
"tree_relationship": true,
"relationship_source": "wikitree_relation_snapshot",
"url": "/people/glasgow-2456.html",
"json_url": "/people/glasgow-2456.json",
"network_url": "/people/glasgow-2456.network.json",
"wikitree_url": "https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Glasgow-2456",
"claim_id": "C-fea7b12d3cee"
},
{
"id": "Glasgow-1157",
"name": "Robert Glasgow II",
"relationship": "sibling",
"status": "unknown",
"status_label": "WikiTree relationship snapshot",
"basis": "tree",
"evidence_ids": [],
"tree_relationship": true,
"relationship_source": "wikitree_relation_snapshot",
"url": "/people/glasgow-1157.html",
"json_url": "/people/glasgow-1157.json",
"network_url": "/people/glasgow-1157.network.json",
"wikitree_url": "https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Glasgow-1157",
"claim_id": "C-1fcf3a9f0ee8"
},
{
"id": "Glasgow-1558",
"name": "Edward Glasgow",
"relationship": "sibling",
"status": "unknown",
"status_label": "WikiTree relationship snapshot",
"basis": "tree",
"evidence_ids": [],
"tree_relationship": true,
"relationship_source": "wikitree_relation_snapshot",
"url": "/people/glasgow-1558.html",
"json_url": "/people/glasgow-1558.json",
"network_url": "/people/glasgow-1558.network.json",
"wikitree_url": "https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Glasgow-1558",
"claim_id": "C-14c9b4a4f2b8"
}
]
},
"claims": [
{
"id": "C-9893257abb43",
"type": "recorded_occurrence",
"subject_ids": [
"Glasgow-3539"
],
"claim": "Mary Glasgow was recorded in Saltcoats — Ayrshire (b. 1613).",
"status": "unknown",
"status_label": "One-Tree profile lead",
"evidence_ids": [
"E-9893257abb43"
],
"notes": "Profile-stated birthplace: Saltcoats, Ayrshire, Scotland",
"provenance": "mapped_record"
},
{
"id": "C-5574aef09979",
"type": "tree_relationship",
"subject_ids": [
"Glasgow-3539",
"Glasgow-1557"
],
"claim": "WikiTree currently connects Mary Glasgow and Edward Glasgow as father.",
"status": "unknown",
"status_label": "WikiTree tree relationship",
"evidence_ids": [],
"notes": "Tree structure only; no documentary conclusion is implied.",
"provenance": "wikitree_parent_field",
"lifecycle": "historical",
"superseded_by": "C-father-audit-20260928-glasgow-1557-glasgow-3539",
"supersession_scope": "The previous relationship assessment is replaced by the reviewed record basis; this does not reject the relationship."
},
{
"id": "C-5c119b598bb1",
"type": "tree_relationship",
"subject_ids": [
"Glasgow-3539",
"Hamilton-31734"
],
"claim": "WikiTree currently connects Mary Glasgow and Catherine (Hamilton) Glasgow as mother.",
"status": "unknown",
"status_label": "WikiTree tree relationship",
"evidence_ids": [],
"notes": "Tree structure only; no documentary conclusion is implied.",
"provenance": "wikitree_parent_field"
},
{
"id": "C-a162832724b5",
"type": "tree_relationship",
"subject_ids": [
"Glasgow-3539",
"Montgomerie-601"
],
"claim": "WikiTree currently connects Mary Glasgow and James Montgomerie as spouse.",
"status": "unknown",
"status_label": "WikiTree tree relationship",
"evidence_ids": [],
"notes": "Tree structure only; no documentary conclusion is implied.",
"provenance": "wikitree_spouse_field"
},
{
"id": "C-eb0b62bd28ab",
"type": "tree_relationship",
"subject_ids": [
"Glasgow-3539",
"Glasgow-1494"
],
"claim": "WikiTree currently connects Mary Glasgow and Jonet Logan as sibling.",
"status": "unknown",
"status_label": "WikiTree relationship snapshot",
"evidence_ids": [],
"notes": "Tree structure only; no documentary conclusion is implied.",
"provenance": "wikitree_relation_snapshot"
},
{
"id": "C-fea7b12d3cee",
"type": "tree_relationship",
"subject_ids": [
"Glasgow-3539",
"Glasgow-2456"
],
"claim": "WikiTree currently connects Mary Glasgow and Cristiane Glasgow as sibling.",
"status": "unknown",
"status_label": "WikiTree relationship snapshot",
"evidence_ids": [],
"notes": "Tree structure only; no documentary conclusion is implied.",
"provenance": "wikitree_relation_snapshot"
},
{
"id": "C-1fcf3a9f0ee8",
"type": "tree_relationship",
"subject_ids": [
"Glasgow-3539",
"Glasgow-1157"
],
"claim": "WikiTree currently connects Mary Glasgow and Robert Glasgow II as sibling.",
"status": "unknown",
"status_label": "WikiTree relationship snapshot",
"evidence_ids": [],
"notes": "Tree structure only; no documentary conclusion is implied.",
"provenance": "wikitree_relation_snapshot"
},
{
"id": "C-14c9b4a4f2b8",
"type": "tree_relationship",
"subject_ids": [
"Glasgow-3539",
"Glasgow-1558"
],
"claim": "WikiTree currently connects Mary Glasgow and Edward Glasgow as sibling.",
"status": "unknown",
"status_label": "WikiTree relationship snapshot",
"evidence_ids": [],
"notes": "Tree structure only; no documentary conclusion is implied.",
"provenance": "wikitree_relation_snapshot"
},
{
"status": "uncertain",
"status_label": "Uncertain father link",
"relationship": "father",
"reason": "The 1677 testament index identifies Mary’s spouse and Saltcoats locality but supplies no parentage; Edward’s attachment remains unproved.",
"basis": "Reviewed father relationship evidence and live WikiTree certainty audit, 28 September 2026",
"source_ids": [],
"identity_scope": "Specific attached father–child pair; later-life identity questions are assessed separately.",
"analysis_links": [
{
"label": "Father evidence and remaining questions",
"href": "/people/glasgow-3539.html#archive-tools"
}
],
"provenance": {
"source": "/assets/research/relationship-assessments.json",
"reviewed_at": "2026-09-28",
"basis": "Review of citations already present in the live biography and maintained findings; no new archival inspection claimed.",
"live_wikitree_status": "uncertain"
},
"assessment_date": "2026-09-28",
"assessment_source": "/assets/research/relationship-assessments.json",
"record_source": "/assets/research/canonical-records.json",
"id": "C-father-audit-20260928-glasgow-1557-glasgow-3539",
"type": "assessed_relationship",
"subject_ids": [
"Glasgow-1557",
"Glasgow-3539"
],
"perspective_id": "Glasgow-3539",
"claim": "The 1677 testament index identifies Mary’s spouse and Saltcoats locality but supplies no parentage; Edward’s attachment remains unproved.",
"notes": "The 1677 testament index identifies Mary’s spouse and Saltcoats locality but supplies no parentage; Edward’s attachment remains unproved.",
"lifecycle": "current",
"historical_claim_ids": [
"C-5574aef09979"
],
"evidence_ids": []
}
],
"research_assessments": [],
"shared_relationship_assertions": [
"C-father-audit-20260928-glasgow-1557-glasgow-3539"
],
"relationship_history": [
{
"id": "Glasgow-1557",
"name": "Edward Glasgow",
"relationship": "father",
"status": "unknown",
"status_label": "WikiTree tree relationship",
"basis": "tree",
"evidence_ids": [],
"tree_relationship": true,
"relationship_source": "wikitree_parent_field",
"tree_status": "uncertain",
"tree_status_label": "Tree-marked uncertain",
"url": "/people/glasgow-1557.html",
"json_url": "/people/glasgow-1557.json",
"network_url": "/people/glasgow-1557.network.json",
"wikitree_url": "https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Glasgow-1557",
"claim_id": "C-5574aef09979",
"lifecycle": "historical",
"superseded_by": "C-father-audit-20260928-glasgow-1557-glasgow-3539"
}
]
}